My New Book

From the West to the East – A Memoir of a Liberal American Rabbi – Purchase directly from the publisher at https://westofwestcenter.com/product/from-the-west-to-the-east/

I am writing now before the month of Elul begins next Wednesday, September 4, because there is much to think about for all of us in this month before the High Holidays in our personal lives, in the United States as we move towards the election and in Israel-Palestine as this war continues, the hostages remain in Hamas’ hands, and terrible danger lurks in the north of Israel and in the West Bank.

My Memoir is a distillation of a life-time of thinking, writing, social justice and liberal Zionist activism, and there is much, I believe, in its pages to stimulate your thinking and reflection before the High Holidays begin with Rosh Hashanah on Wednesday evening, October 2nd.

Here is praise of the book:

“From the West to the East is a beautifully written and thoughtful guide to the challenges facing American Jewry, shared by one of America’s most influential rabbis.”Congressman Adam Schiff, author of Midnight in Washington – How We Almost Lost our Democracy and Still Could, lead Manager for the first impeachment trial of President Donald J. Trump, lead congressional author of “The Protecting our Democracy Act”

“In this moving memoir, Rabbi Rosove models how a liberal Jew can be a passionate lover of Israel while remaining uncompromisingly faithful to the prophetic tradition. Now, at a critical crossroads for the community, he offers an indispensable guide to help American Jews navigate through a time of crisis.” -Yossi Klein Halevi, senior fellow, Shalom Hartman Institute, author of the New York Times bestseller, “Letters to My Palestinian Neighbor

“In his powerful and revealing memoir, Rabbi Rosove guides us through a consequential life as the religious leader of one of the most historic and influential congregations in the United States. He confronts some of the most challenging moral issues of our time, including Israel-PalestineIt’s a book full of lessons to help us navigate a world that often seems unrecognizable.”Zev Yaroslavsky, former member of the Los Angeles County Board of Supervisors, author of Zev’s Los Angeles – From Boyle Heights to the Halls of Power, A Political Memoir

From the West to the East is a beautifully written, intensely personal and deeply profound book. John’s love for Judaism, America and Israel shine through on every page. A rabbi’s rabbi, his memoir is a must read for rabbis and all who are interested in the contemporary Jewish experience.-Rabbi Ammi Hirsch, Senior Rabbi, Stephen S. Wise Free Synagogue, Manhattan, NY – author The Lilac Tree, and host of “In These Times Podcast”

“Rabbi Rosove recounts the personal odyssey of a unique rabbi unafraid to wrestle with man and God in his quest for Tikun Olam.” -Anat Hoffman, Founder and Chair of Women of the Wall, former Executive Director of the Israel Religious Action Center

“Rosove’s memoir illuminates how the interplay of activist courage and faith have been builders of American liberal Zionism.” -Robin M. Kramer, former chief of staff for both Los Angeles Mayors Richard Riordan and Antonio Villaraigosa, and past president of the board of trustees of Temple Israel of Hollywood

The Qualities of a Great Leader

Rabbi Jonathan Sacks, the late Chief Rabbi of the United Kingdom, wrote:

“Great leaders are great not just because they care for their own people – everyone except a self-hater does that – but because they care for humanity. That is what gives their devotion to their own people its dignity and moral strength… To be an agent of hope, to love the people you lead, and to widen their horizons to embrace humanity as a whole – that is the kind of leadership that gives people the ability to recover from crisis and move on. It is what made Moses, Isaiah and Jeremiah three of the greatest leaders of all time.”

As we prepare to vote in the coming election, I’ve been thinking a great deal about those personal qualities and virtues that make for great leadership, and I want to offer here my own thoughts and conclusions.

Taking everything into account, based on my own 40+ years leading synagogue communities and being engaged actively in a number of not-for-profit and political organizations watching good and bad leaders succeed and fail, I believe that great leadership requires, in addition to Rabbi Sacks’ insights, not just vision and high moral rectitude, but the love of truth, the love of humanity, the virtues of humility, gratitude, generosity and wisdom, a respect for the dignity of every individual and a commitment to further the common good.

Great leaders constantly are honing their skills, are curious, committed to learning and embrace experimentation in their work, and seek to synthesize information and apply what they learn carefully and thoughtfully. They don’t fear failure because they know that from failure they learn the most. They delegate responsibility to enable colleagues and followers to do their best work knowing that they can’t do everything themselves. They recognize that there are others who know more and are better able and well-suited in ways in which they themselves lack appropriate expertise and skills.

Great leaders support those they lead, offer fair criticism so that others may grow in their own right and according to their capacity, goals and dreams. Great leaders are available to advise and act as sounding boards for new ideas. They credit others generously for their respective successes both privately and publicly. They take pride in others’ accomplishments and thank them personally for what they do on behalf of the leader and/or the organization of which they are active members and/or leaders. They rely upon team-work and encourage everyone to do their best. They take responsibility when things go wrong and never blame others for mishaps and failures. They are open to constructive criticism and how they themselves can improve and grow. They work hard but they take time for themselves, for their families and friends. They encourage the people with whom they work to do the same because they understand that everyone needs balance between love and work.

In recent years, the servant-leader model of leadership, encompassing a values leadership approach in religious institutions and non-profit organizations has taken hold. Rabbi David Ellenson (z’l), the emeritus president of the Hebrew Union College – Jewish Institute of Religion, wrote:

“[The servant-leader] is servant first… It begins with the natural feeling that one wants to serve. Then conscious choice brings one to aspire to lead. The servant-leadership model is one that promotes such values as collaboration, trust, foresight, listening, and the ethical use of power and empowerment… relationship-driven leaders are more empathetic, patient and tolerant. They approach decision-making subjectively, using personal values as a guide, and they examine how each option will impact others. They are approachable, strive for harmony amongst their employees and work to build consensus and trust. They also admit when they are wrong and seek constructive criticism… they are adept at listening and forging personal connections.”

Doris Kearns Goodwin, the American presidential historian, offered these insights:

“Leadership is the ability to use one’s talent, skills, emotional intelligence to mobilize people to a common purpose and to make a positive difference in people’s lives. The qualities important for leadership are humility, empathy, resilience, self-awareness, self-reflection, the ability to create a team where people can argue with you and question your assumptions, and the ability to communicate to people with stories to make people feel a part of what you are saying. The most important thing is the willingness to take a risk because the ambition for the greater good has become greater for you than for yourself.”

Great leaders take risks even when they know they will be criticized and possibly attacked. “You must be headlights and not tail-lights,” said Representative John Lewis.

Leadership is often difficult, painful and lonely. Leaders need the support of allies who join them in their mission. They need, as well, trusted loved ones with whom the leader can confide his/her fears, doubts and despair, and who can advise them by always being honest with them.

Any government, political party, company or business, religious or educational institution, non-profit organization or cause succeeds or fails based upon the moral values, competency, skill and vision of its leader. It is therefore in the best interest of everyone to choose their leaders wisely and carefully and, in an ongoing manner, evaluate critically and fairly the leader against high moral and ethical standards.

Zev Yaroslavsky, a former long-time Los Angeles City Councilman and Member of the LA County Board of Supervisors, wrote: “I have long believed that the key question is not which positions politicians will support or oppose. It’s the issues they’re willing to lose their office over in the name of principles that matter.”

As we move closer to voting, perhaps these ethical and functional standards of great leadership can help guide us in our decision-making in the voting booth.

Post-DNC Recommendations

For us political junkies who crave not only a Harris-Walz White House victory on November 5, but keeping the Senate and winning back the House, I offer below an analysis of “Punchbowl News AM” published this morning (August 23) about the critical races being run by Democrats Sherrod Brown in Ohio and Jon Tester in Montana. I’ve met both Senators and they are worthy of our financial support. They must win for Democrats to keep the Senate.

I have given financial support also to Colin Allred in Texas, Jackie Rosen in Nevada, Bob Casey in Pennsylvania, Ruben Gallego in Arizona and, though he doesn’t really need it, my friend Adam Schiff in California.

My family and I are taking Michelle Obama’s inspirational advisory to heart – for everyone to do something going forward until election day – and that means giving financially to those campaigns that will be critically important to Democrats on November 5: phone banking, visiting Nevada or Arizona (for Californians), or other swing states to do whatever those state campaigns require of volunteers, and to be certain that everyone we know of voting age (family, friends and colleagues) are registered to vote and vote by mail or at the polls on election day.

Thankfully, the DNC and the Harris-Walz Campaign have hired thousands of lawyers in the swing states and across the nation to combat in the courts the MAGA Republican legal efforts to subvert the election by changing state election rules to favor Trump and Republicans, denying the vote to black and brown registered voters, and preparing for the day-after election Trump’s and his minions denial of Kamala’s victory, assuming that Trump loses the election, again.

Democracy and freedom really are on the ballot, and I hope that Democratic voters plus Independents and traditional Republicans, who have come to realize what is at stake and recognize Trump for the snake oil salesman and would-be autocrat that he is, will defy predictions of a close presidential election and produce a landslide for Kamala Harris and Tim Walz not only to keep the election-deniers to the minimum but to vanquish the criminal-Trump and Trumpism once and for all.

The following is the Punchbowl News AM report today of a conversation with Chuck Schumer at the convention:

“With West Virginia already flipping to the GOP, Republicans just need to win one more seat to retake the Senate majority. Their best pickup opportunities are in Montana and Ohio. But Republicans are also pouring millions into presidential battlegrounds like Nevada, Arizona, Pennsylvania and Michigan, where Democrats are defending seats.

Ticket-splitting: Democratic Sens. Jon Tester of Montana and Sherrod Brown of Ohio can’t win their races without a massive chunk of so-called “ticket-splitters” — voters who choose former President Donald Trump in the presidential race and Tester or Brown in the Senate race.

As we’ve written before, this is an increasingly rare phenomenon. We asked Chuck Schumer how Tester and Brown could possibly win enough ticket-splitters to overcome the massive edge Republicans have in those states. Schumer said it’s up to the candidates themselves — and Harris — to not veer too far to the left:

“There’s a good chunk of Republicans — those who voted not for Trump but for Nikki Haley, and even before that [Ron] DeSantis — who really don’t like Trump. So as long as our presidential candidate, but also our Senate candidates, can convince them that they’re mainstream, not too far left, and they care about their state above all, they can get a lot of those votes.”

Plato warned that passivity and withdrawal from the political realm carry terrible risks: “The penalty that good [people] pay for not being interested in politics is to be governed by [people] worse than themselves.”

For Your Children and Grandchildren in Colleges and Universities

In May, I posted a blog entitled “Talking Points for College Students Concerning Palestinian Protests.” College and University students are now preparing to start classes in the coming weeks and they are likely going to encounter either demonstrations on their campuses on behalf of Palestinians in Gaza and against Israel or fellow students who have an incomplete understanding of the Hamas-Israel War and the Israeli-Palestinian conflict.

In addition, in next week’s Democratic National Convention, Palestinian protestors and their supporters are planning mass protests outside the convention hall. Vice-President Kamala Harris has already encountered and responded to similar protests in her campaign.

I have written at some length about the Hamas-Israel War and the Israeli-Palestinian conflict in the republishing of my 2019 volume Why Israel and its Future Matters – Letters of a Liberal Rabbi to his Children and the Next Generation (republished after October 7 and available on Amazon) and in my recently published Memoir From the West to the East – A Memoir of a Liberal American Rabbi (available from the publisher at https://westofwestcenter.com/product/from-the-west-to-the-east/

I offer once again those talking points for you to share with your college age children and grandchildren and, for that matter, with anyone else you think might benefit from what I have written. You can access that blog here:
Talking Points for College Students Concerning Palestinian Protests – 31 Friday May 2024  

Coping with Anxiety and Fear

These are anxious times – be it as a consequence of American presidential politics, or threats to our democracy, or the suffering begun on October 7 and continuing in the Gaza Strip, Israel and the West Bank, or in Russia’s war against Ukraine, or whatever each of us is experiencing personally. Anxiety can be suffocating. Hopefully, each of us has ways to relieve the tension that builds up from the sense of powerlessness of which anxiety and fear are the consequence. Strategies can include turning off the news, exercising, listening to music, binging on TV series’ re-runs and old films, eating chocolate and ice cream.

Over the past 30 years, I’ve collected wise quotations from Jewish and world literature on every imaginable theme. I checked today the theme of “anxiety and fear” and found following. I hope at least one or two help bring you a measure of calm and/or inspiration.  

“The only thing we have to fear is fear itself – nameless, unreasoning, unjustified terror which paralyzes needed efforts to convert retreat into advance.” —President Franklin D. Roosevelt (1882-1945)

“You gain strength, courage and confidence by every experience in which you really stop to look fear in the face. You are able to say to yourself, ‘I lived through this horror. I can take the next thing that comes along.’” —Eleanor Roosevelt (1884-1962)

“There is only one way to happiness and that is to cease worrying about things which are beyond the power of our will.” —Epictetus (1st-2nd Century AD Greek Stoic philosopher)

“Anxiety does not empty tomorrow of its sorrows, but only empties today of its strength.” —Charles Spurgeon (19th century English Baptist Preacher)

“Nothing diminishes anxiety faster than action.” —Walter Anderson (20th century American painter and writer)

“You cannot always control what goes on outside, but you can always control what goes on inside.” —Wayne Dyer (20th-21st century American author)

“Life is ten percent what you experience and 90 percent how you respond to it.” —Dorothy M. Neddermeyer (20th-21st century psychotherapist)

“Nothing can bring you peace but yourself.” —Ralph Waldo Emerson (1803-1882)

“Calm mind brings inner strength and self-confidence, so that’s very important for good health.” —Dalai Lama (1935- )

“There are moments when all anxiety and stated toil are becalmed in the infinite leisure and repose of nature.” —Henry David Thoreau (1817-1862)

 “What else does anxiety about the future bring you but sorrow upon sorrow?” —Thomas á Kempis (14th-15th century Dutch-German author)

“Grant me the serenity to accept the things I cannot change, the courage to change the things I can, and the wisdom to know the difference.” —Pastor Reinhold Niebuhr (20th century American Ethicist)

“If you don’t like something, change it. If you can’t change it, change your attitude.” —Maya Angelou (1928-2014)

“America must not become a nation of onlookers. America must not remain silent. Not merely black America, but all of America. It must speak up and act … for the sake of the image, the idea and the aspiration of America itself… When I was the rabbi of the Jewish community in Berlin under the Hitler regime, I learned … under those tragic circumstances that bigotry and hatred is not the most urgent problem. The most urgent, the most disgraceful, the most shameful, and the most tragic problem is silence.” —Rabbi Joachim Prinz (1902-1988; words spoken on the steps of the Lincoln Memorial, 1963 March on Washington)

“Despair is not an option.” —Yaron Shavit, Deputy Chairman of the Executive of the Jewish Agency for Israel, President of the 38th World Zionist Congress  

“Get in good trouble, necessary trouble…Do not get lost in a sea of despair.” —Congressman John Lewis (1940-2020)

“The world is a very narrow bridge; the important thing is not to be afraid.” —Rabbi Nachman of Breslov (Ukraine, 1772-1810)

Kamala Harris’ Superb Nuanced Statement About the Necessity of Ending the Israel-Hamas War Now

Tags

, , , ,

Introduction: I could not have hoped for a better, more nuanced, comprehensive, and urgent statement from Presidential Candidate Kamala Harris about this awful Israel-Hamas War. If you did not hear her give it in her masterful verbal presentation, here it is (click onto the blue below to see her actually deliver her statement):

I just had a frank and constructive meeting with Prime Minister Netanyahu. I told him that I will always ensure that Israel is able to defend itself, including from Iran and Iran backed-militias such as Hamas and Hezbollah. From when I was a young girl collecting funds to plant trees for Israel to my time in the United States Senate, and now at the White House, I have had an unwavering commitment to the existence of the State of Israel, to its security and to the people of Israel. I’ve said it many times, but it bears repeating. Israel has a right to defend itself and how it does so matters. Hamas is a brutal terrorist organization. On October 7th Hamas triggered this war when it massacred 1200 innocent people including 44 Americans. Hamas has committed horrific acts of sexual violence and it took 250 hostages. There are American citizens who remain captive in Gaza – Sagi Deo Hen Hirsch Goldberg, Poland Idan, Alexander Keith Siegal Omer Neutra and the remains of American citizens, Judy Weinstein, God Haggai and Itai Hen are still being held in Gaza. I have met with the families of these American hostages multiple times now, and I’ve told them each time they are not alone and I stand with them, and President Biden and I are working every day to bring them home. I also expressed with the Prime Minister my serious concern about the scale of human suffering in Gaza, including the death of far too many innocent civilians. And I made clear my serious concern about the dire humanitarian situation there with over 2 million people facing high levels of food insecurity and half a million people facing catastrophic levels of acute food insecurity. What has happened in Gaza over the past nine months is devastating. The images of dead children and desperate hungry people fleeing for safety sometimes displaced for the 2nd, 3rd, or fourth time. We cannot look away in the face of these tragedies. We cannot allow ourselves to become numb to the suffering, and I will not be silent. Thanks to the leadership of our President Joe Biden, there is a deal on the table for a ceasefire and a hostage deal and it is important that we recall what the deal involves. The first phase of the deal would bring about a full ceasefire including a withdrawal of the Israeli military from population centers in Gaza. In the second phase, the Israeli military would withdraw from Gaza entirely, and it would lead to a permanent end to the hostilities. It is time for this war to end and end in a way where Israel is secure, all the hostages are released, the suffering of Palestinians in Gaza ends, and the Palestinian people can exercise their right to freedom, dignity and self-determination. There has been hopeful movement in the talks to secure an agreement on this deal; and as I just told Prime Minister Netanyahu it is time to get this deal done. So to everyone who has been calling for a ceasefire and to everyone who yearns for peace, I see you and I hear you. Let’s get the deal done so we can get a ceasefire to end the war. Let’s bring the hostages home and let’s provide much needed relief to the Palestinian people. Ultimately, I remain committed to a path forward that can lead to a two-state solution. I know right now it is hard to conceive of that prospect; but a two-state solution is the only path that ensures Israel remains a secure Jewish and democratic state, and one that ensures Palestinians can finally realize the freedom, security and prosperity that they rightly deserve.  I will close with this. It is important for the American people to remember the war in Gaza is not a binary issue. However, too often the conversation is binary when the reality is anything but; so I ask my fellow Americans to help encourage efforts to acknowledge the complexity, the nuance and the history of the region. Let us all condemn terrorism and violence. Let us all do what we can to prevent the suffering of innocent civilians, and let us condemn antisemitism, Islamophobia and hate of any kind, and let us work to unite our country. I thank you.

The Art of Growing Old – Thoughts for Joe Biden

Tags

, , , ,

I love Joe Biden – always have. He has heart and his personal losses, wonderful marriage and loving children and grandchildren, the esteem of his colleagues and from the Democratic Party, and his understanding of America’s purpose in the world have made him a great president with accomplishments that will be compared with FDR and LBJ. But, he’s having a hard time aging and letting go, and that’s sad to watch. We all get old, if we’re lucky. At almost 75, I’m beginning to understand the effects of aging much better myself – mild memory loss, loss of quickness of mind, more aches and pains, physical weariness earlier in the day, etc. etc. etc. – but so much positive comes with aging too – a greater perspective, enhanced appreciation, deepening gratitude, wider generosity of heart, inner calm.

Joe is a great man, and perhaps his resistance in stepping aside is part of the reason for his greatness, that his dogged persistence in making a difference, to do what few human beings have been successful in doing – reaching the highest office in the world – blinds him to the new reality in his life – getting old. Joe’s accomplishments as a leader, politician and statesman are very great, but his time to step aside has come – that’s obvious to any objective observer.

Step aside Joe – we love you. We admire you. Your legacy will stand the test of time. You will rise even higher than #14 in the long list of presidents as history judges you so very well.

Here are some inspired thoughts about getting older, both from the perspective of one who ages and from philosophers, anthropologists, sociologists, artists, and writers. If anyone knows Joe personally who reads this, share these quotations with him and Jill. He has nothing to fear and everything to gain. He has been and can be still our hero and example.

Aging is a gift – “Aging is a gift, a chance to keep growing, learning and experiencing life in new ways. It’s about defying limitations and embracing the possibilities that lie ahead… It’s not about passively accepting age it’s about actively living each day to the fullest, wrinkles and all.” -David S. Cantor

Senility and Aging – “I feel as if I’m losing all my leaves. The branches, and the wind, and the rain… I don’t know what’s happening any more. Do you know what’s happening?” -“The Father” with Anthony Hopkins

Compensation of Growing Old – “The compensation of growing old, Peter Walsh thought, coming out of Regent’s Park, and holding his hat in his hand was simply this, that the passions remain as strong as ever, but one has gained – at last! – The power which adds the supreme flavour to existence – the power of taking hold of experience, of turning it round, slowly, in the light.” -Virginia Woolf, Mrs. Dalloway

Respecting the Aged – “Respect an old man who has lost his learning: remember that the fragments of the tablets broken by Moses were preserved alongside the new.” – -Babylonian Talmud, B’rachot 8b

The Aging Artist – “The art of fresco was not work for old me…one paints with the brain and not with the hands.” -Michelangelo

“Clouds of affection from our younger eyes / Conceal the emptiness which age descries. / The soul’s dark cottage, battered and decayed. / Let’s in new light through chinks that time hath made.”-Rembrandt

Characteristics of Old-Age Style in Work of Greatest Painters and Sculptors – “A sense of isolation, a feeling of holy rage, developing into what I have called transcendental pessimism: a mistrust of reason, a belief in instinct. … the feeling that the crimes and follies of mankind must be accepted with resignation… a retreat from realism, an impatience with established technique and a craving for complete unity of treatment, as if the picture were an organism in which every member shared in the life of the whole.” – Kenneth Clark, Aging Artists

The Complete Life – “The complete life, the perfect pattern, includes old age as well as youth and maturity. The beauty of the morning and the radiance of noon are good, but it would be a very silly person who drew the curtains and turned on the light in order to shut out the tranquility of the evening. Old age has its pleasures which, though different, are not less than the pleasures of youth.” -W. Somerset Maugham, The Summing Up

Loving Life – “No man loves life like him that’s growing old.” -Sophocles, Acrisius

Growing Old – “Grow old along with me! / The best is yet to be, / The last of life, for which the first was made.” -Robert Browning

The Secret of Old Age – “The secret of a good old age is simply an honorable pact with solitude.” -Gabriel Garcia Marquez, One Hundred Years of Solitude

Continuing On – “There is only one solution if old age is not to be an absurd parody of our former life, and that is to go on pursuing ends that give our existence a meaning.” -Simone de Beauvoir, The Coming of Age

The Blessings of Age – “For age is opportunity no less / Than youth itself, though in another dress. / And as the evening twilight fades away / The sky is filled with stars, invisible by day.” -Henry Wadsworth Longfellow, Morituri Salutamus

A Truth About Growing Older – “As you grow older, you will discover that you have two hands, one for helping yourself, the other for helping others.” -Audrey Hepburn

The Life of the Elderly – “We cannot live the afternoon of life according to the program of life’s morning.” -Carl Jung

The Art of Growing Old – “The art of growing old is the art of being regarded by the oncoming generations as a support and not a stumbling block.” -Andre Maurois, An Art of Living

“Israel Must Stop Its ‘Dimona Talk’” – by Ehud Barak

Tags

, , , ,

Introductory Note: This op-ed, published today in Israel’s Haaretz newspaper, was written by Israel’s former Prime Minister and Minister of Defense and once the most decorated soldier in Israel’s history. It is both a pragmatic and visionary response to the extremist, self-destructive and dangerous rhetoric of right-wing messianic members in the current Israeli government. I urge you to read his analysis carefully. Haaretz is a subscription newspaper. I have urged my readers to subscribe for years as it is among the most important publications produced for thinking people in Israel itself and in the English speaking world.

Op-ed – Ehud Barak – Former Israeli Prime Minister – July 14, 2024 – Haaretz

“We have reached nine months of war. Despite the sacrifice and courage our soldiers and commanders display every day, and despite the harsh blows felt by Hamas and Hezbollah, still none of the war’s goals have been met. What’s more, the strategic paralysis exhibited by Israel’s leadership risks a comprehensive and prolonged regional conflict, while the deepening rift with the United States expands, and the country is being plunged into international isolation. This must not be allowed to happen.

This complex situation has generated a growing discourse in recent weeks, including in this newspaper and on television channels, centering on expectations or demands that Israel threaten to use its alleged nuclear capabilities as a means of emerging victorious from this crisis. There are those who even propose to consider actually making use of this ability.

This discourse, to the best of my understanding, is unnecessary, unhelpful and may even be harmful. It reflects feelings of frustration and helplessness, which are not desirable counsels to strategy and statesmanship. What is required here is common sense, not fantasies.

The failure to achieve the war’s goals does not stem from Israel’s use of conventional weapons alone, rather, it was the reluctance to determine on October 8 what we want the “day after” the war to look like. This reluctance derives from the prime minister’s considerations regarding his political survival and the extortion by extremists in his coalition against him. It has led to treading water and wasting military achievements that were reached at the cost of blood.

The solution to the impasse is to first remove the obstruction that caused it, that is, to replace the head and remove reckless figures from the government – and by not resorting to measures that many of those promoting them don’t even understand their implications.

Second, say “yes, but!” to the U.S. initiative to create an “axis of moderation” under its leadership, centering around Israel, Egypt, the United Arab Emirates and perhaps Saudi Arabia as well, that will ready itself against the “axis of resistance”: Iran, Syria, Hezbollah, Hamas and others, led by Russia. We saw the axis of moderation’s potential on the “night of the missiles” launched from Iran in April. That’s the appropriate strategic horizon for Israel.

In the words of Benjamin Netanyahu, Israel is simultaneously an all-powerful nation saving the world from a new Islamo-Nazi threat, and a whining victim abandoned to its fate of being threatened with annihilation by “Amalekites” from without and “traitors” from within. This bipolar perspective is disrupting his judgment of reality and dragging many confused Israelis into it.

Readers of newspapers in Israel can get the impression that, on the one hand, we can destroy and annihilate all our enemies one after the other at the slightest provocation, swiftly and at a tolerable price. On the other hand, the whole world is against us, and we can only rely on the Almighty and on Dimona, the site of an Israeli nuclear reactor.

That is not the case. Even today, in July 2024, Israel is the strongest state – militarily and strategically – in the region. The “axis of moderation” the United States is proposing is the most effective deterrent against an overall regional war at any foreseeable future. This axis is also the correct framework to ensure victory, if such war were to break out.

The threat of the “Dimona option” and the discourse around it doesn’t convey determination or power. They radiate insecurity, weakness and confusion, imbalance and a pinch of panic. The reason is that Iran knows our strategic capabilities far better than the Israeli public. The ayatollahs in Tehran are extreme fanatics, but they are also calculated chess players and certainly not stupid.

Similar to North Korea’s leadership – who has no intention of dropping a bomb on South Korea or Japan, understanding such actions would lead North Korea back to the Stone Age – Iran’s nuclear program has two goals. The first and foremost one is to ensure the regime’s survival. The second is to build – under the umbrella of the “strategic balance” that would be created by a military nuclear capability – a reliable conventional threat. The late and cursed Qassem Soleimani, called it a “ring of fire” which would exhaust Israel in a prolonged war of attrition until it weakens and collapses.

This “ring of fire” is based on proxies like Hezbollah, Hamas, the Houthis and others. They are equipped with drones, rockets and missiles, some of them highly accurate, and have terror units trained with precise weapons, like the Kornet anti-tank missile, operating within the population and prepared to conduct years of guerrilla warfare, even under occupation.

The U.S.-led “axis of moderation” is the right answer to the current situation, where, despite the rapid progress, Iran is still hesitating to develop military nuclear capabilities. If it decides to do so, it will still take it another year or so to get to a crude nuclear weapon and a decade to build an initial arsenal. But Iran is already a nuclear threshold state, meaning Israel and the United States have no surgical way to stop it from obtaining nuclear weapons.

This requires an alignment between Israel, the U.S. and regional allies. Ali Khamenei and the ayatollahs know that Israel hasn’t hesitated to attack states in the region to thwart their production of nuclear weapons. But they also know that for the past 50 years, Israel has been making efforts and huge investments to ensure an adequate response to a situation in which a state in the region obtains nuclear weapons. Despite the attempts to stop it, Israel is not without means.

Strategic capabilities are at their best when they remain a threat. During the Cold War between the United States and the Soviet Union, this approach even kept at bay wide conventional confrontations. For reasons familiar to anyone who dealt with the matter, such abilities are not suitable means for preventive attacks. There’s no logic in considering them in a situation that is not a real, immediate, irrevocable existential threat, which cannot be thwarted in any other way.

This is definitely not our situation. Certainly not in view of the existing alternatives – joining the “axis of moderation” and replacing the failed Israeli leadership. These two steps will provide a quick, simple and much cheaper solution than resorting to the “Dimona option.”

The primary global danger posed by Iran’s nuclearization is that it will set off a chain reaction of nuclearization in Saudi Arabia, Egypt and Turkey, thereby bringing down the entire regime of the Treaty on the Non-Proliferation of Nuclear Weapons, commonly known as the Non-Proliferation Treaty or NPT. By its very creation, the U.S.-led axis can answer this challenge as well, in that it provides a “nuclear umbrella” to Saudi Arabia and Egypt. (Turkey already has such an umbrella through its membership in NATO.)

It is no coincidence that nuclear weapons have not been used in 80 years. Israel’s famous declaration that it will not be the first country to introduce nuclear weapons into the region remains the correct policy.

There is also no reason to remove Israel’s nuclear ambiguity since, as noted, there is nothing the Iranians do not know. Lifting the ambiguity would only be seen as a gimmick meant to assuage the general despondency in Israel. Such a move, and also insinuations a la “Remember Dimona,” are liable to give Iran the incentive and the legitimacy to accelerate the race toward nuclear weapons, on the grounds that it is threatened by Israel’s “nuclear capability,” which, unlike Iran, has not even signed the NPT.

Israel is indeed in a complex situation requiring courage, discipline, sober, reality-based strategic thinking, making difficult decisions and determination in carrying them out. The current leadership is equipped with almost none of these. Alien considerations are leading it – and us with it – toward the abyss.

“Dimona talk” in the current context is unnecessary and harmful, and only distracts us from what is truly needed: to immediately replace the sinkers of the Titanic and join the axis of moderation with the United States. Such talk contributes no understanding, common sense or a relevant course of action for the challenge we face. We must end it immediately.”

“I am an Israeli American Jew. Bulldozing Palestinian homes is personal for me” by Ben Linder

Tags

, , , ,

Ben is a friend who I met when I served for a year representing the J Street Rabbinic and Cantorial Cabinet on the Board of J Street, a national pro-Israel, pro-peace, pro-democracy organization based in Washington, D.C.

I urge you to read Ben’s heart-breaking account (published in the Jewish Journal of Northern California) of his Palestinian friends living in the West Bank who have become victims of the extreme right-wing Israeli government’s de facto (leading to de jure) illegal annexation of an increasing amount of West Bank territory. As the tumult in American politics, the horror of October 7 and the Israel-Hamas War continue, news about the West Bank has not broken through nearly enough in the west.

I am grateful to Ben for bringing this one single tragedy that just took place in the South Hebron Hills to our attention. Read his heart-breaking account here: https://jweekly.com/2024/07/10/i-am-an-israeli-american-jew-bulldozing-palestinian-homes-is-personal-for-me/