Earlier this week, I was asked to participate with two others in a press conference in Washington, D.C. on behalf of J Street which was convening in its 6th Annual National Conference.
I joined Dr. Charles Gati, Senior Research Professor of European and Eurasian Studies of Johns Hopkins SAI, a former state department consultant and Holocaust survivor, and Dylan Williams, Vice President of Government Affairs for J Street. I was asked as a former co-chair of the Rabbinic Cabinet of J Street and now as the national chair of the Association of Reform Zionists of America.
We were being questioned about President Trump’s nomination of David Friedman to be the next United States Ambassador to Israel. All three of us were strongly opposed to the nomination.
We oppose Friedman because of his long-standing support of the settlement enterprise, his public opposition to the two-state solution, and his assaults against large segments of the American Jewish community that support the two states for two people’s resolution of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict.
We said that Friedman’s policy positions run counter to the long-held positions of every American President in the last 25 years who have supported the two-state solution, his slander of J Street supporters as “worse than kapos,” his charge that the ADL is led by a bunch of “morons,” and that President Obama and Secretary Kerry are anti-Israel and anti-Semites.
These positions and statements ought to disqualify Friedman’s appointment to any position in the government, let alone as the chief American diplomat in one of the most sensitive regions in the world.
I was asked by Al Jazeera English whether or not I accepted Friedman’s statements at his Senate hearing in which he recanted virtually every position he ever held and every statement he ever made vis a vis Israel and the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. I said that I do not accept anything he said in the hearings as reflective of his true beliefs and as an indication of how he would conduct himself should he be confirmed by the Senate in the next few days.
In particular, I was moved by Dr. Charles Gati. He was ten years old when the Nazis invaded Budapest in 1944 and ordered the expulsion and murder of all that city’s Jews. Charles was spared being shot and thrown into the Danube River due to pure luck.
His opposition to Friedman was based not only on his policy positions and ill-temperament but because Friedman showed how woefully ignorant he is of Jewish history and the history of the Holocaust when he callously used the word “kapo” to describe J Street supporters.
After hearing Dr. Gati, I told him and Dylan Williams that meetings ought to be arranged this week one-on-one between Charles and every reasonable Republican Senator. I am certain that Charles would persuade any reasonable leader to oppose this nomination.
Read: Friedman’s ‘kapo’ comment should disqualify him as ambassador to Israel, The Hill
Susan Meyer said:
Thank you. I am so proud!
Deeply Important Idea, John. Bravo
Leigh Tobias, Ph.D. FIPA
462 N. Linden Drive #334,Beverly Hills, CA 90212
Confidentiality Notice: This email and any attachments are confidential and may be the subject of legal professional privilege. If you are not the intended recipient, any use, disclosure or copying of this document is not authorized. If you have received this document in error, please immediately notify the sender by email or telephone and delete this email from your computer. Thank you for your cooperation and courtesy.
Note: Please do not communicate urgent clinical material via email.
Susan Adler said:
John, thank you for your assessment and your idea. Are you aware of Dr. Gati being given the opportunity to meet with the Republican leadership?
I would be surprised if it actually happened.
I, like you, don’t believe Friedman’s responses to questions posed to him in the hearings. He knew what the Senators wanted to hear and responded accordingly…much like his would be boss did during the campaign.
In an aside, my mother, brother and grandmother were already tied together, by rope, on the banks of the Danube, along with hundreds who were about to be shot into the river. They were reciting the Sh’ma when a friend of the family, dressed as the SS Arrow Cross, started screaming at them and somehow got them out of the line. Lives turned on a dime!!!
Years later, I asked my mother how, after what she witnessed, she could still believe in God.
Her answer was simply, after what I’ve been through, how could I not???