Tags
bible, christianity, Faith, god, jesus
“A lack of humility explains a whole lot about our dysfunction and divisiveness, which we won’t repair without a resurgence of it. We’ve been at one another’s throats in part because we’ve been unhumble — and thus unable to acknowledge that there might be good reason for someone’s divergent opinion, that it’s not necessary to win every argument, that the public good matters as much as our private satisfaction and that a healthy democracy requires compromise, forgiveness, grace. We’ve had unhumble governments, and that has intensified partisanship and exacerbated its toll.” (Frank Bruni, NYTs Opinion, November 16, 2026)
I could not agree more and especially in this post-election and Thanksgiving season.
The virtue of humility (Hebrew: ענוה – anavah) is worth considering far more not only as a virtue necessary in our national political and government leadership, but in every other kind of leadership and communal engagement, in business and the professions, non-profit organizations, entertainment and the arts, religious organizations, neighborhood, family and friendship groups.
Of all the virtues, humility is a foundation stone for other virtues, including appreciation, gratitude, patience, respect, dignity, generosity, compassion, empathy, loving-kindness, justice, and peace. The supreme importance of humility is evoked in a Talmudic passage inscribed over many synagogue sanctuary arks around the world –דע לפני מי אתה עומד (Da lifnei Mi atah omed – Know before Whom you stand). (1) This teaching is a reminder of our human finitude on the one hand, and divine transcendence on the other.
Consider the place of humility on a spectrum in which at one end are the extremes of hubris, arrogance, conceit, vanity, egomania, self-aggrandizement, hard-heartedness, and shamelessness. On the opposite end are the extremes of meekness, diffidence, submissiveness, subservience, victimization, humiliation, self-deprecation, self-denigration, self-denial, self-effacement, and a sense of unworthiness.
The Yiddish short story Bontshe Shvayg – Bontshe the Silent, written by I.L. Peretz (2), is a morality tale about a meek Jew who never spoke up for himself despite the indignities he suffered at the hands of bullies, antisemites, and even the chief prosecutor of the Holy Tribunal. In comparison, Moses, the most powerful human being in the biblical literature, is described as “a very humble man, more humble than anyone else on the face of the earth.” (3)
Comparing the nature of Bontshe Shvayg and Moses clarifies what Judaism teaches about the nature of humility.
A rabbinic legend explains:
“One day God observed the shepherd Moses retrieving a stray lamb. Taking the diminutive creature lovingly into his arms, the to-be-prophet cradled it and returned it to its mother. God noticed and said: ‘Since you tend the sheep of human beings with such compassion, you shall be the shepherd of My sheep, Israel.’” (4)
Moses’s assumption of responsibility for his flock’s welfare and his compassion for the vulnerable creature constitute the character trait of humility that caught God’s attention.
The Hebrew Bible notes that when Moses heard the divine voice call to him from the Burning Bush (5), the prophet’s heart and soul opened to the experience of awe and wonder, but when God commanded Moses בא אל פרעה (Bo el Par’oh – Come to Pharaoh) (6) and demand freedom for the enslaved Israelites, Moses demurred because he believed that he did not possess the requisite self-confidence, courage, and agency necessary to confront the most powerful ruler in the ancient world. God reassured him and promised to put words into his and his brother Aaron’s mouths (7) and back them up with plagues to shock Pharaoh into submission and allow the enslaved Israelites to leave Egypt.
Rabbi Louis Jacobs wrote that humility occupies the golden mean along the spectrum between the polar extremes in the human character, as I describe above, from self-denial and unworthiness at one end to pride and conceit at the other:
“Humble people are … confident and competent in themselves so much that, as a result, they seek to self-actualize by helping others. Humble people are still self-efficacious; they just don’t feel the impetus to boast about themselves, but instead let their actions speak for their ideals. To be humble is not to think less of oneself, but to think of oneself less.” (8)
Bontshe Shvayg is the ultimate victim beaten into submission. His, however, is not “humility.” It’s humiliation. To the contrary, humble people understand that they are nobly born by virtue of being created בצלם אלוהים (b’tzelem Elohim – in the Divine image). (9) They accept their self-worth, virtues, talents, skills, capacities, and abilities but have no need to prove themselves to others. They do not brag or boast or call attention to themselves because they are too busy putting the interests of others first.
What does a humble person today look like? Rabbi Jacobs listed many habits of humble people worth our attention. Humble people
- base their decision-making on a sense of shared purpose and not self-interest,
- listen without feeling the need to express their opinions and narratives,
- do not interrupt others, nor self-reference when another is speaking,
- make room for others, exercise self-restraint, demur and defer. They emulate God by undergoing צמצום (tzimtzum – contraction) to enable others to rise, act, share leadership, thrive, and contribute to the community. They have no need to say the final word. They permit the wisdom of others to prevail. They speak only when asked or when it is their role to do so as a teacher, leader, mentor, coach, guide, or friend,
- are curious and perpetual learners. They embody the Mishnaic sage’s dictum: “Who is wise? The one who learns something from everyone”, (10)
- put others at the forefront of their thoughts and brag about others, giving credit easily while the prideful brag and take the credit for themselves. They do not call attention to themselves as experts. They have mastered the art of silence and active listening,
- are receptive to constructive criticism and seek it because they understand that positive feedback is a means toward their self-improvement and evolution.
My childhood Rabbi Leonard Beerman (11) was a giant in the North American Reform Jewish movement and an indefatigable social critic of corruption wherever he saw it. He never hesitated to speak truth to power, and with his resonant conscience-based voice, he set a high ethical and social justice standard for his congregants and for those in the wider Jewish community in Los Angeles and nationally, as well for many leaders in the Los Angeles’s Christian and Muslim communities. As morally compelling a public figure that Rabbi Beerman was, he was also a deeply humble man. He once confessed:
“I live with uncertainty and doubt. But what I have learned is that doubt may be the most civilizing force we have available to us, for it is doubt that protects us from the arrogance of utter rightness, from the barbarism of blind loyalties, all of which threaten the human possibility.”
Senator-Elect James Talarico displays this important virtue of humility and evokes palpable relief from the hubris, arrogance and egotism of far too many leaders in public life today.
This blog is edited from a chapter in my book Finding Your Moral Compass – Jewish Values for the Twenty-First Century (Toronto: University of Toronto New Jewish Press, 2025), 65-69.
Notes
- Babylonian Talmud, Berachot 28b.
- Isaac Leib Peretz (1852 –1915), a Polish Jewish writer and playwright.
- Numbers 12:3.
- Midrash, Shemot Rabba 2:2.
- Exodus 3:2.
- Exodus 10:1.
- Exodus 5:1.
- Rabbi Louis Jacobs (1920-2006), The Jewish Religion: A Companion (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1995).
- Genesis 1:27.
- Mishnah, Pirkei Avot 4:1.
- Rabbi Leonard Beerman (1921-2014), founding rabbi of Leo Baeck Temple, Los Angeles.