Tags

, , , ,

An open letter to Gadi Eisenkot: Military dominance has opened a rare diplomatic window. If you become Israel’s next prime minister, seize it before more conflict and growing American antipathy close it

By Daniel Kurtzer and Aaron David Miller

November 17, 2026

Dear General Eisenkot,

The celebrated Israeli singer Yehudit Ravitz sang a classic line: “Things that you see from there, you don’t see from here.” We have worked on America’s Middle East policy under Republicans and Democrats for decades, and have visited, lived and worked in Israel for longer than we can remember. We never forget that those living outside Israel, who do not face its security challenges themselves, need to think humbly and carefully before offering advice on its security concerns and priorities. We know well that the things we see from here are different from what Israelis see and experience there.

Nonetheless, you stand at the threshold of what could be one of the most consequential moments in Israel’s history. The dark shadow of October 7 looms long and large, challenging hope and exacerbating fear, and will do so for some time. At the same time, if you succeed in becoming Israel’s next prime minister, you will have a rare opportunity to begin reshaping its foreign and security policy. In doing so, you could open a pathway to a future that might – we emphasize might – offer more opportunities for peacemaking and fewer imperatives for conflict and war.

Now in its fourth year of conflict on multiple fronts, in Gaza, Iran, Lebanon, Syria and Yemen, Israel is far more secure than it was before October 7. Indeed, in our assessment, at no point since the state’s establishment has Israel been this secure, this dominant militarily and at peace with five Arab states. Israel paid a terrible price for weakening Hamas and Hezbollah, as did Palestinian civilians in Gaza and the West Bank, and civilians in Lebanon. Your challenge now, while keeping Israeli security requirements front and center, would be to translate that power and strength into conditions that could reduce conflict and foster durable political agreements.

Today, Hamas has been hollowed out militarily, leading to its announced willingness to disarm, a commitment that surely needs to be tested and its implementation monitored. The Lebanese government is more willing than ever to take risks, seemingly intent on assuming control over all its territory and recognizing that this will require reining in Hezbollah and, ultimately, Israel’s withdrawal from Lebanon. Syria remains an intriguing work in progress, with the Sharaa government considering a security accord with Israel without making the return of the Golan Heights a prerequisite. And Iran, while very much down but hardly out, has seen its nuclear program substantially diminished and its economy left in shambles.

An Israeli friend once told us that when the security situation is dangerous, Israel is unwilling to consider negotiations that could involve concessions on territory and other issues; when the security situation is favorable, Israel feels no need to consider negotiations and possible concessions. Israel is in a strong position today, stronger relative to its enemies than it has been in decades. The question, then, is whether you are ready to lead boldly and persuade the body politic that agreements with neighbors and a healthy relationship with the United States today can be a force multiplier for Israel’s security in the future.

If you succeed in forming a government, it will be time to bring the words “Palestinians,” “peace” and “two states” back into the political discourse. As veterans of both failed and successful negotiations, we are not arguing that you should plunge into final-status negotiations now. Indeed, there is still no Palestinian leadership that can claim control over all Palestinian arms or command the support of a majority of Palestinians in the occupied territories.

But you can take consequential steps, some of which are already on your agenda: stopping settler violence, lawlessness and terror; preventing further land grabs; dismantling illegal outposts; reasserting the rule of law; and halting the galloping annexation through actions on the ground and legislation. These steps are all critical, but they are not enough.

Where Benjamin Netanyahu worked hard to bolster Hamas’ standing and diminish the role of the Palestine Liberation Organization and the Palestinian Authority, you need to reverse course: restart a dialogue with the PA; strengthen security cooperation; stop starving the PA of funds; and instead of weakening Palestinian self-governance, support it in a way that creates an environment for resumed political dialogue.

In Gaza, your government should test the Board of Peace by withdrawing to the Yellow Line and allowing the National Committee for the Administration of Gaza and the International Stabilization Force to enter the Strip. You should make clear that Israel’s first step puts the onus on Hamas to live up to its declared willingness to begin disarming. Each phase of Israel’s withdrawal should be tied to Hamas’ completion of a corresponding phase of demilitarization. Your government should also facilitate critical humanitarian assistance, especially with winter arriving, by allowing in more tents, tarps, pumps, generators, heating equipment and other necessary items under credible supervision.

You will need to think regionally. Your government should engage the Gulf Arabs and the U.S. administration to press Hamas in Gaza, and work with the United States, especially Central Command, on regional security issues that matter as much to Israel’s Arab neighbors as they do to Israel, particularly those concerning Iran. Israel needs a more realistic strategy for dealing with Iran than the notion that military action can unseat the regime.

With Iran’s nuclear infrastructure substantially damaged, this is the moment to seek to lock in those gains through bold diplomatic action. Indeed, a first visit to Washington should be preceded by visits to Cairo, Amman and Abu Dhabi, signifying a new region-wide commitment to coordinate strategy and pursue diplomacy.

You will, of course, assess your own political circumstances and decide whether the benefits of the approach we suggest are worth the risks. That assessment should take account of one additional reality: What we see and experience here in American politics and society is different from what Israelis might be seeing from there.

We are greatly concerned about rising antipathy toward Israel, driven in part by its military actions in Gaza after October 7 and by the perception that the current caretaker prime minister conned the administration into an unnecessary war of choice against Iran. In the minds of many Americans, Israel is no longer a sympathetic David but an aggressive Goliath. What the American people saw changed their attitudes and influenced their political choices. The polls and the statements of Israel’s critics in both parties make that clear. Even among some stalwart supporters, there is talk of the need to significantly reduce support for Israel.

This is not yet a full-blown crisis. But without significant changes in Israel’s policies and its approach to the legitimate security challenges it faces, attitudes among Americans and our elected representatives will only harden.

We know that you have political calculations to make and Israeli public attitudes to assess. We also realize that taking these steps is no panacea. But they will surely enhance Israel’s image and credibility in the United States and internationally. They might also pave the way for peacemaking and a healthier U.S.-Israel strategic partnership.

Moreover, if you choose to form a government with Israel’s Arab parties, that would be an important demonstration of your commitment to Israel’s democratic character. It would represent an important advance in Jewish-Arab relations in Israel and improve the status of the state’s Arab citizens. This, too, would help strengthen Israel’s position in the United States, the region and beyond.

We offer these views with great respect and humility. The stakes now are existential, extending beyond politics here or in Israel. They cut to the core of how best to guarantee, 78 years after the creation of the State of Israel, the security and prosperity of a Jewish, democratic nation living in peace and security with all its neighbors.

——————————————-

Daniel C. Kurtzer, former U.S. ambassador to Israel and Egypt, is the S. Daniel Abraham Professor of Middle East Policy Studies and professor of the practice in international relations at Princeton University’s School of Public and International Affairs.

Aaron David Miller is a senior fellow at the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace and a former State Department Middle East analyst and negotiator in Republican and Democratic administrations.

https://www.haaretz.com/opinion/2026-11-17/ty-article-opinion/.premium/eisenkots-greatest-test-may-be-knowing-what-to-do-with-israels-power/000001a1-df09-d1ce-a9a3-ff1b77f60000